Tamarack - An Institute for Community Engagement
Tamarack Home Learning Centre Vibrant Communities Community Life
Vibrant Communities The Unique Needs & Role of Canada's Large Cities
 

Alan Broadbent and Mary W. Rowe joined us November 10, 2004 for the second seminar in our three-part Urban Canada tele-learning series. The seminar higlighted the unique needs and role of Canada's large cities.

On this page you'll find:

Introduction

More than 80% of Canadians live in urban areas making Canada the second most industrialized nation in the world.

In recent years the mayors of our five largest cities came together as part of the C5 initiative to promote their unique needs. Statistics show that immigrants overwhelmingly choose to settle in large metropolitan cities. Mid-sized cities and municipalities are struggling to manage growth while suffering the effects of downloading. And cities have become a hot political topic with our current prime minister promising a "new deal" for cities. Tamarack's three-part Urban Canada series highlights the issues our cities are facing.

In 1999, Avana Capital, through its Ideas that Matter division, initiated a series of discussions on urban autonomy in Canada which resulted in the publishing of Toronto: Considering Self-government, Towards a Greater Toronto Charter, and the creation of the C5 (Vancouver, Calgary, Winnipeg, Toronto and Montreal), a city collaboration that includes meetings of Mayors and civil society leaders on a regular basis.

Avana Capital was honoured on May 26th, 2004 by the Canadian Urban Institute for its work in advocating a new role for Canada’s largest urban regions. Alan Broadbent, CEO, Avana Capital Corporation and Mary Rowe, director of Ideas That Matter, received the City Renewal Award for their efforts in the public realm.

"Whether from desire or necessity, to attend school or find work, for love or acceptance, people are moving to Canada’s biggest cities. And they are staying." says Alan.

Back to top.

Summary of the seminar

Alan and Mary discussed:

Hub cities & urban regions

  • Urban regions - cities and municipalities who interact with each other regularly and have reached a critical mass
  • Hub cities - Most provinces generally have a center where most of their social and economic activity and innovation occurs. These are "hub cities."

Why should we be concerned about cities?

The issue of cities has grown in importance as urbanization increased. Twenty-first century Canada is predominantly an urban country. Most Canadians live in or near our large or second-tier cities where the modern industries of information and design are housed.

Modern economies are based on competition between city regions (the fundamental economic unit) and not nation states. If we are interested in economic prosperity, we have to be worried about the health of our cities.

Cities are where things happen (i.e. they are the media and cultural centres of the country and the place where immigrants and refugees are more likely to settle). Through their sheer size, they are the place where social and cultural innovation takes place.

Hub cities and urban regions are not necessarily better or more desireable places to live than other communities, they are just where economic innovation and activity takes place.

It's important, therefore, to consider the city's power to control its own destiny. Currently they lack the power and resources to do just that.

What's needed

  1. Power
  2. Resources
  3. A seat at the table

The principles of "subsidiary" and "particularity"

The level of government closest to the people requiring a particular service should deliver that service because they are best able to determine fit. They should have the fiscal capacity to fund the service.

One size does not fit all. A tailored approach to governance is required.

We need to invest in our strengths, those areas that are most likely to produce assets. Canada's current wealth contributors are our urban regions. An investment in them will be an investment in the entire country.

Back to top.

Additional material

  • Foreword from "A New City Agenda" - This foreword by Alan Broadbent argues that large urban regions should have more control of their own destiny and should have access to the tools required to look after themselves.
Back to top.